PDP3-
The Arab-Israeli Conflict (1967)
Author
Bio:
The author of the first excerpt is Abba Eban. Abba Eban was an Israeli
ambassador, diplomat, and politician. He felt that he was a professional
protector of Israel; he had a very strong nationalist view of life. He was
against Zionism, as well. The Palestinian National Charter, the third excerpt,
was drafted by the Palestine Liberation Organization. This organization used
armed struggle in order to achieve the liberation of Palestine.
Date/Context:
These texts were written during the late twentieth century, in the 1960s, after
World War 1. The discrepancies between Arab and Israel had remained constant
after World War 1, then exceedingly intensified after Israel declared statehood
in the late 1940s which then led to their greatest conflict: “Six Days War” of
1967. This time period was generally consumed by religious and nationalist
disagreements and general harshness.
Summary:
In Abba Eban’s speech, states that the main topic of his speech will be about
the harsh past and hopeful future of the Middle East. His central idea,
however, revolves around his homeland of Israel and the unfairness it has received.
However, his speech ends by discussing the ways to end this controversy and
that is by recognizing the necessity of true cooperation and true contact with
other countries. The path to achieving this positive outcome, the author
believes, lays within the city limits of Jerusalem. He asks both developing
countries and great powers to make changes, or even sacrifices, to the way that
they view themselves and other countries or nations. The second excerpt talks
about how the Security General and others need to follow the Charter’s
guidelines and principles to ensure the best possible outcome for them. The
final excerpt then discusses the relationship of Arab Palestinian people and
their identity. It also distinguishes the main points of a Palestine community
and the different prospects of Arab unity. Finally, the excerpt talks about how
necessary the liberation of Palestine is to Arab unity and vice versa and the
way that Zionism is very unnecessary and not beneficial to any society,
especially Israel.
Key
Quotation: “Israel’s rights to peace, security, sovereignty,
economic, development and maritime freedom-indeed its very right to exist-has
been forcibly denied and aggressively attacked. This is the true origin of the
tension which torments the Middle East.”
Allison's analysis of "The Arab-Israeli Conflict" was very well done. She provided many of the important parts of the document within her summary. I think that it was very important that she included what he believed the way to bring the country back to peace. What Allison did not discuss was what the charters discussed in the second excerpt. She had left out what the Israeli forces should do to bring peace to their country.
ReplyDelete